California Car Buyer's Bill of Rights

Contact Us
About Our Practice
FAQ Answer Page
Other Useful Links
- Lemon Law

California's 2-Day Right to Rescind an Automobile Purchase

     Effective July 1, 2006, California law requires dealers to offer a 2-day contract cancellation option on used vehicles with a purchase price of less than $40,000.00.  In practice, this new law is proving rather useless, at least to consumers.
    Existing law did not, contrary to popular belief, provide automobile buyers with an automatic 3-day right to rescind.  That automatic 3-day right applies to some contracts, like home mortgages and dance studio contracts, but not automobiles.  The new Car Buyer's Bill of Rights does not change existing law in that regard.
    What undoubtedly started as a noble attempt to create a new Bill of Rights for car buyers was indeed a noble gesture. Unfortunately, like any other modern attempt to create a new law to benefit consumers, by the time our legislators caved in to changes insisted on by the big money lobbyist, the law ended up doing little, if anything, for consumers.
  First of all, the right is not automatic, as it should be and was originally intended.  Rather, the consumer has to buy the right (the law does not require the dealer to charge for it, but allows the dealer to charge for it - same difference).  The price varies depending on the price of the car, from $75.00 to $399.99.  Plus, if you exercise your right to return the car, the dealer can, and of course will, charge you a restocking fee, of $175.00, $350.00, or $500.00, depending on the price of the car (but you do get a credit for the amount paid for the option).
    In practice, virtually all car buyers who have financed (does not apply to cash sales, or sales where buyer arranged her/his own financing in advance) the purchase of a used car under $40,000.00 since the law was enacted, initial the box in a special form declining to purchase the option, many unknowingly, and the vast majority of the rest because the finance manager says "You don't want to pay an extra $500.00 to buy a 2-day cancellation option, do you?
    The good news is that car buyers who want to cancel their car contracts still have the other consumer statutes that have always been on the books (since at least the 1960's) to help them get their money back when the deal turns out to be worse than they were led to believe, such as the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, and the Automobile Sales and Finance Act, among others.  
    In any event, the new law, as indicated above, applies only to conditional sales contracts, which are contracts which require future payments (not cash sales, or not contracts where the consumer comes to the dealership with their own financing pre-arranged), or a lease, but only if the lease provides for payments by which the bailee or lessee agrees to pay as compensation for use a sum substantially equivalent to or in excess of the aggregate value of the vehicle and lessee will become, or for no other or for a nominal consideration has the option of becoming, the owner of the vehicle upon full compliance with the terms of the lease agreement. (This would rule out leases with large residual payments).
     The new law also requires sales contracts for sales that are financed by or through the dealer to include the amount charged for an often useless service contract, a worthless theft deterrent device, a usually unnecessary insurance product like GAP, the amount charged for a worthless surface protection product, any debt cancellation agreement, and the amount charged for the used vehicle contract cancellation option agreement, within the listing of "itemization of the amount financed." This was a nice addition to the existing detail required by the Automobile Sales and Finance Act.  Even better, the Dealer is required to list all these "add-ons" on a separate sheet of paper, listing the price for each, and indicating what the monthly car payment would be with, and without, the "add-ons."
    The new law prohibits a seller, in consideration of an assignment of a conditional sale contract, from receiving or accepting from the assignee (the financial institution) any payment or credit based upon any amount collected or received under the contract, or to be collected or received, in excess of specified amounts. This limits the undisclosed kickback to the dealer ("mark-up") to 2 1⁄2% for 60-month finance contracts and 2% for contracts longer than 60 months.
    This new law expands existing provisions regarding advertising to prohibit a dealer from advertising or selling a vehicle as "certified," or using similar descriptive terms to imply that the vehicle meets the terms of a used vehicle certification program, unless that vehicle meets specified criteria, and makes violations of this provision actionable under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act and the Unfair Competition Law, and as false advertising.
    The new law prohibits a dealer from adding charges to a sale or lease contract without the buyer's consent or inflating a payment or extending the maturity of a contract for the purpose of disguising the actual charges for goods or services.
    The new law requires a dealer that obtains a consumer credit score from a consumer credit reporting agency for use in connection with an application for credit for the purchase or lease of a motor vehicle for non-commercial use to provide the credit score to the consumer prior to the sale or lease of that vehicle.  There is, unfortunately, no penalty for a violation of this provision.

  -Call us to see if we can help-

(925) 943-6400

The Law Office of MICHAEL R. QUIRK

1615 Bonanza Street, Ste. 207

Walnut Creek, California 94596

NOTICE: Information printed here is not legal advice.  The information is general in nature, and is not intended as a substitute for legal advice or a legal opinion on a specific individual fact scenario. Individual rights, remedies and obligations vary; laws frequently change. Your specific facts should be reviewed by this office, or another California attorney emphasizing auto dealer fraud, lemon law, fair debt collection, credit protection, and other consumer fraud and consumer law issues, before taking any action. Site content approved by Michael R. Quirk.

© 1999-2017 Law office of Michael R. Quirk -All Rights Reserved